Surgery
- Surgery: A game in how to fail an osce. Guy had colostomy with parastomal hernia. So I looked, got told off for running commentary (don’t do it to a surgeon) did the abdo exam, thought I’d finished and spent the next minute with the examiner looking at me and saying come on then.. have you really finished? I was in such a state by then, couldn’t remember if I’d done all the exam and didn’t want to continue it if I had so kept deciding to re-examine then stopping like some demented jack in a box. Questions on the stoma, very brief. Asked about possible reasons for the stoma // Patient had a parastomal hernia. examine and present findings. Asked why patient has had a stoma (Hartmann's Vs AP resection), types of stoma and indications. Asked what i would examine next - i said perineum, hernial orifices and external genitalia. Examiner then asked me to examine hernial orifices - normal except for two tattoo marks from radiotherapy (which the examiner told me everybody else missed!) then asked to put it all together and say why patient has a stoma - colorectal cancer, surgery, stoma which hasn't been reversed and radiotherpy for malignancy! // patient with colostomy and scars. Was asked to examine groin – patient had rash on one side but not on the other and also a radiotherapy tattoo mark but was unable to put it all together.
- Abdominal exam- stoma- colostomy. Asked why the gentleman may have it in place. Then what else I would like to check... when I mentioned that I would like to check the anus as it would differentiate between an abdomino-perineal resection and an anterior resection, the examiner then made me examine the perineum without gloves and made every student after me do it too, so know how to examine it!!! I can't remember much about this station, it was my first one and the perineum examination threw me a bit!! // "Examine this patient's abdomen" ...the patient had a stoma. I don't know why I was still panicking, I saw the stoma and focused too much on it. I completely forgot to check for bowel sounds or shifting dullness!!! The stoma was the main thing, the man had a midline laparotomy scar as well, so I was quizzed on what I thought the stoma was (a colostomy) and why (left sided etc etc) operation the patient had, I said Hartmann's because the examiner had told me the anal canal was patent. That was apparently correct, the examiner then asked me why this patient might have had Hartmann's I said colorectal carcinoma or acute diverticulitis which was also apparently fine. The examiner then asked what ELSE it could be, I then said an A-P but I would have expected the rectum to be over sewn (i.e. anal canal NOT PATENT). The examiner then said "REALLY?" and I said " YES" and then had a million other ways of saying the same thing, and the examiner started shaking his head....I'm still not sure what he wanted me to say!!!
- GI - - abdo exam of patient with stoma, Urostomy bag / ileal conduit due to bladder cancer plus ascites
- Surgical - Abdo examination - small bowel obstruction post op, nephrectomy scar present, asked on causes of SBO, different types of resection
- Surgical exam- Lady with multiple scars including midline laparotomy, left subcostal, plus stoma in right iliac fossa. Couldn't find any other signs or think of explanation for scars. I mentioned I would test for hernias to complete the exam, was told to procced but bell went. Was told she had Crohn's and asked about its surgical treatment. Didn't get round to mentioning about stenosis, fistulae, perianal abscesses etc.
- Breast examination, left upper outer quadrant mass, DDx, genetic counselling
- Surgical exam - mastectomy and examination of other breast, followed by discussion about breast cancer, risk factors, treatment options etc.
- Surgery - peripheral vascular exam of legs, arterial history, varicose veins (needed to be stood up) // Peripheral vascular examination of claudicant asked about Buerger's Test. Values for ABPI and how would do it Surg stations was peripheral vasc- this was difficult and bitty- buergers was positive but the reactive hyperaemia was mild and i think many students said it was negative. Useful to do this test on a real patient before the exam! Ques- what would you expect his ABPI to be? What is normal? Explain how to do it. // SURGERY I had a gentleman with and amputated foot, lots of weird pigmentation around his ankles, I was asked to do a vascular examination of the legs, so got to him to stand up looking for varicose veins, he had none, so went on to arterial, had to Buerger's test to, I made it up completely, I could not see the leg going pale at all, but there was and obvious hyperaemic reaction when he swung his leg round, he had obvious haemosiderin deposits too, I think I would've done better if I knew what type of amputation he had, he asked me why what is a positive Buerger's test, why do u get a hyperaemic reaction, what does it mean if he has haemosiderin deposits, what was an ABPI, what reading would indicate critical ischaemia, this station was never ending!!!
- Vascular - gentleman with an aortofemoral bypass graft (scars) and claudication. Poor pulses. // surgery: peripheral vascular disease....he asked: there is a scar in right groin and on medial aspect of right knee put it together...femoro-popliteal bypass...then he said feel the bypass and it has a hard lump on it..then he said to present the lump and a lumo!!! duo station...sly... // Surgery - peripheral arterial examination on an Asian patient with an amputated foot and scars from a fem-pop bypass on the left hand side, but normal pulses on the right. Very nice examiner, I examined the patient and presented and then it was more an informal discussion rather than proper question and answer, I got a question wrong and the examiner just corrected me. // Surgery: Peripheral vascular examination, did not want me to perform burgers when I tried. No radial, femoral pulses on the left, Sternotomy scar. Turn out to have lots of scars which were very hard to spot, got asked about a scar...which vein and what it was for (CABG), also about another scar which was a fem-pop bygraft // Surgery – assess this patient’s vascular STATUS (means varicose veins AND arterial examination). Man had no varicosities but had absent pulses below femorals bilaterally, also had positive Buerger’s test in right leg, had to scars over upper thighs and midline abdomen, was an aorto-bifemoral bypass operation. I was then asked what other reasons he would have had this operation besides atherosclerosis, no idea.
- Peripheral vascular examination - femoral atherosclerosis
- The next patient I was told to "examine the legs", I did not know if it was a surgical, locomotor or neuro station so the examinrer just said "why don't you ask the patient to stand up." The patient had huge varicose veins. I was asked to examine this and the peripheral vascular system of the leg. Then asked about the pathogenesis and anatomy of varicose veins. // pvd, Qs asked-where do u suspect the prob to besuperficial femoral (needed basic anat knowledge), treatment
- Peripheral Vascular Disease. Patient had cold white legs. Pulses difficult to find. His radial pulse on the left was weaker on the left than on the right. If you found this sign you were asked about the possible causes and in most cases ridiculed by the especially unpleasant examiner. Which was nice.
- vasc- wasn’t sure if this was varicose veins or arterial I did arterial though there were tourniquets I didn’t touch them. bit ulcers and all sorts- not my best station! I said the patient had oedema- examiner asked what type, I said pitting. then I was asked to demonstrate this. it wasn’t pitting! so he said what is it called! I said dependent oedema? the examiner said 'LYPHOEDEMA' 'have you ever heard of lymphoedema?' yes I had thanks for making me feel thick! // Surgical – pls examine this pt’s legs – fat ulcer on lat malleolus. Did arterial exam and went with arterial ulcer but q’s on venous ulceration... // surgery - arterial examination. only question was why arterial on grounds of inspection? obvious discolouration and arterial ulcers etc //
- Hernias - inguinal and incisional, keloid scars, direct hernia // Surgery : Examine this persons groin. Direct Inguinal hernia. Asked about treatment options. // Surgery: Guy with lump in the inner thigh- lipoma. Had to test for cough impulse, lying and standing, felt scrotum for masses, mentioned that I would like transilluminate th mass. Examiner was happy and asked me for differentials and to say why I thought it was not that: e.g. femoral artery aneurysm - NOT pulsatile, saphena varix - NO cough reflex, sebaceous cyst -NO punctum etc. This sounds a litte bit daunting but it really was a nice station, and the examiner was very encouraging throughout. For these 2 stations, students are given a list of the questions they will be asked well in advance on the revision courses and handouts. The mark sheets are also available online so it's a good idea to use them and make sure you can answer the questions about different scenarios.
- surgical: the patient had two lumps. One on her right forehead and another of right forearm. I went through site, size, shape, colour...etc..and said findings were most consistent with lipomas. The examiner said that was correct but wanted other differentials..we talked about sebaceous cysts, lymph nodes, AV malformations, dermoid cysts and other weird and wonderful lumps and bumps.. at the end he asked if I would refer this lady ..I said 'the lesions appear benign on examination but I would refer to be safe'..examiner said 'good’. examiner then asked what my first line imaging modality would be ' I said ultrasound'..examiner said 'good'.
- Surgery - incisional hernia (only seen when getting the patient to raise his head), bronze skin + ?hepatomegaly (mentioned haemochromatosis but not sure). Lots of people thought this patient was normal. Got asked lots of questions on scars, hernias and causes of hepatomegaly. // Abdo – no idea, lots of scars, 1 in RIF, I mentioned it could be appendicectomy (examiner looked pleased), instructions actually said, ‘examine this patient’s abdomen, who has a lump in the groin’. So you had to do abdo exam, and then examine his scrotum and hernial orifices. He also had a slight splenomegaly I thought, but others thought it was hepatomegaly, he could not lie flat so this made it difficult to palpate the abdomen. He was tender in the lower abdomen. No idea what was going on. Examiner then asked what the lump in the groin was, I said an inguinal hernia.
- Abdominal exam- man had midline laparotomy and ?appendicectomy scar. Examiner walked off when my back was turned and was replaced by another guy. Maybe this meant he had no signs apart from his scars- I couldn't find any. Examiner said the scars were related. I suggested kidney transplant and he asked why would there be a laparotomy. I said it wasn't a kidney then, and he said he didn't say it wasn't a kidney. Confusing. I think he had an incisional hernia which I was meant to test for- getting him to lift head while lying down. // Surgery - Abdominal - laparotomy scar, AP resection scar, colostomy, urinary catheter but no abdo signs.
- surgery: inguinal hernia AND abdo exam AND scrotum exam AND examine a strange lump on the back......... not sure i could find a connection between the 2.. i think he had massive hepatomegaly which i gave as a cause for the hernia although i dont think i examined the scrotum properly because i then was asked a lot about clinical findings in a hydrocele and what i would find in the scrotum of someone with an indirect hernia and a hydrocele ie patent processus vaginalis - ie would you be able to feel any discrete masses? // Examine hernia, expected to include scrotum, asked about whether I would refer the atient, to give differntials, then asked a bit about anatomy, lymphatic drainage of the groin and surrounding structures etc - and what a mesh is adn how it work, why heneeds op, risks, is the lump malignancy, can he drive and when after, and when he can go back to work,,,it was not consenting them.
- Surgery - sebaceous cyst of scalp, a really awkward 10 mins, had finished the examination (where's the red desc lamp!) in about two mins, had to give a differential - lipoma, neurofibroma. Examiner asked me to list the structures of the scalp and then explain to the patient what she should have done about it.
- Surgery - man with a ganglion on the back of his hand. Just exmaine a lump/bump and test median/ulnar nerve function (the guy was a dr himself.. maybe the hernia didnt show up)
- Surgery - Lump in the neck. Assess lump to see if its a thyroid lump and then assess throid status. How would you Ix- TFT, FNA, USS, biopsy. Complications of throid surgery eg, bleeding, infection, damage to laryngeal nerve, damage to parathyroid glands- hypocalcaemia.